planet LOST

Thursday, April 30. 2009

LOST: The Variable

Damn.  If Desmond is "The Constant" then who is "The Variable?"  Well, we kinda-sorta find out.  And things definitely take an interesting twist.  Many spoilers abound, and theorists put your thinking caps on....

Quasi-Recap

So at last we get away from the "daddy issues" bit only to discover that Faraday has "mummy issues." ... sigh....

Through a series of odd flashbacks, some of which are events we've seen parts of before, we discover that Widmore was the one funding Faraday's research at Oxford, and that yes folks, Eloise Hawking is Daniel's mother.  Seems she had big plans for him, but his research sent him in a spiraling mess of mental instability.  Not nearly to the point of his girlfriend/assistant Teresa, but leaving him a shell of his former genius self.  She gives him a blank journal (the one we've seen) for graduation.   Widmore comes to see him directly after the scene where he sees the news of Oceanic 815 and is saddened, but doesn't know why.

Widmore asks him to go to the island, and tells him that it will cure him.  Later his mother returns to him, and reaffirms this, and Daniel agrees to go, since it will make her proud of him.  On the way out, she runs into Charles.  It's revealed that he is Daniel's father, which we could have guessed....

MEANWHILE....  Desmond gets rushed into the ER for his gunshot wound which Benjamin Linus has dealt him.  Eloise shows up to apologize to Penny, and reveals to her that she is Daniel's mother.  Strangely enough, little Charlie is left in the waiting room with an unknown nurse.....  cue the impending music.

Now then.  Back on the 1977-time island, Faraday emerges from the sub.  "Hey, Miles!"  He's returned from Ann Arbor (and god help me if I can figure this one out!)  He's on a mission, and after much ado, finds Dr. Chang, and reveals the mission:  He's here to prevent "The Incident" which will happen if they tunnel any further down in their construction of The Orchid station.  A release of the energy "30,000 times stronger" than what is killing the workmen will be released at the Swan site, which will require the pressing of the button, which Desmond will fail to press, which causes the crash, etc. etc.  Oh, and he lets slip to Chang that Miles is his son, and that he's from the future.  Way to hold up the credibility there Dan-o!

He convinces Jack and Kate to help him get to the Hostiles, since he knows how to fix it.  Curiously enough, Juliet helps them out by giving them the "fence" code, but its clear that she's doing this to get Kate away from Sawyer....  ooh, I smell a rivalry going on here!

On the way out, Jack, Kate, and Daniel are stopped by Radzinski and his henchmen, and a firefight ensues.  They manage to escape, but when Radzi goes to get Sawyer, er I mean LaFleur, they find Phil in the closet.....  Not good!

Faraday posits to Jack that it is they who are "the variables", that they have the power to change events that will happen.... 

Kate, Jack, and Daniel find the hostiles' camp.  Faraday calmly walks up to the camp, gun in hand, and demands to speak to Eloise.  He finds Richard, who maybe recognizes him from his run-in in '54.  Faraday wants to know where the bomb is, so he can prevent the impending doom.  Blam!  Faraday is shot, by none other than Eloise herself.  Doh.

Not much of a recap, I know, but I think I got the main points.....  upward and onward.

The Variables

OK, so if the Losties are the variables, and they do what Faraday has planned on, can they indeed stop "The Incident" from occuring, and prevent the entire timeline from playing out?  I think so.  Actually it makes perfect sense, as they've already done it in the world Locke, Sun, and Ben are in.  When the island took "the five" back to the island from the plane, and the incident never happened, then they crashed onto that island.  Following me yet?

The Constant

Ah, but here's the kicker.  If they are the variables, and Desmond is "The Constant," what will that mean for him?  We've seen him sort of bouncing around in time, and if what he's experiencing is in fact his destiny, and everything "course corrects" back to that.... then there's a big paradox going on, or is about to happen.

Another Paradox

Faraday also tells Jack that "they don't belong here" in 1977.  If that's the case, then why would he feel the need to try to change things here in this time?  Wouldn't he come to the conclusion that they shouldn't try to change things?

Daniel, RIP?

It looks as though our favorite scraggly scientist is dead.  But is he? Will Richard intervene? Can he?  Or will the Losties follow through on his plan, which means there will be no crash, no freighter, no back-to-'77 and no gunshot for Daniel?  You also have to love the fact that this moment must have been what separated Eloise and Charles....  but one other thing....

Wouldn't this mean that there's a little baby Daniel somewhere on the island?

Charlotte

Yeah, and the strange little man Charlotte spoke of is indeed Daniel.   BUT.  If this 1977 island is their "present" as he says, how would he know that they've had this conversation, and where does his affection for her come from previously?  Oh yeah, there's more to this Faraday time-travel business than meets the eye.

Juliet vs. Kate

Interesting also that Juliet would seemingly betray Sawyer by giving Kate the fence code, right at the moment Sawyer asks Kate to choose between him and Jack.  This way Juliet gets rid of Kate and keeps Sawyer for herself.  Yeah, that will come back to us.

Miles and Pierre

Will anything become of the revelation to Change that future-Miles is his son?  Or does Chang just think Faraday a total nut case and that'll be the end of it?

Charlie

Now for my "he must be smoking crack" theory of the week.  Here it is, ready?

Little Charlie Hume is in fact Charlie Pace.  Note that he gets left alone with "this nurse" that Eloise Hawking the doc says will watch him.  Would explain the connection that Desmond and Charlie had, wouldn't it?  And since technically he would be the grandson of Eloise and Widmore, wouldn't it make sense that they would take some sort of measures to protect him?  Like maybe sending him back to 1977?

Or maybe not.  I just think its more than an homage to older-Charlie that they named him that.


I still can't help feeling that things are getting rushed though.  The first 15 minutes of the episode especially felt that way, just one thing after the other in such quick succession.  Slow down guys!!




Posted by PlanetLOST in characters, episodes, opinions, reviews, theories at 10:28 | Comments (14)
Defined tags for this entry: desmond, ellie, faraday, time travel, widmore
Related entries by tags:
LOST: Namaste
LOST: The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham
LOST: 316 [Spoiler filled analysis ahead!]
LOST: 316 [Recap, SPOILERS!]
LOST: This Place is Death [Analysis - SPOILERS!]
Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)
#1 kitty on 2009-04-30 10:43 (Reply)
"and reveals to her that she is Daniel's father."

HUH???? doesn't make sense!!! Eloise revealed that she is Dan's father????????
#1.1 Chris (Homepage) on 2009-04-30 10:44 (Reply)
Um. Oops. Yeah, Fixing that one in a second. Thanks. Mind was getting ahead of typing fingers :-)
#2 MangaKhan on 2009-04-30 11:02 (Reply)
Hawking did not say the nurse will watch Charlie, the doctor said the nurse will watch Charlie.
#2.1 Chris (Homepage) on 2009-04-30 11:08 (Reply)
noted and mis-remembered :-D I didn't write in my hastily typed notes who said it... Thanks
#3 Kevin on 2009-04-30 12:02 (Reply)
Can someone refresh my memory... Faraday tells Jack that Desmond will stop pushing the button one day and THAT causes his plane to crash. BUT wasn't Desmond pushing the button after the losties got to island. Or did I misunderstand something in Desmond's timeline?
#3.1 Chris (Homepage) on 2009-04-30 12:05 (Reply)
He failed to push it -once- which just happened to be the event that brought the plane down. He kept on pressing it until he was found by Locke....
#4 Hugonaut on 2009-04-30 12:57 (Reply)
This whole button pushing thing is kind of freaky. While there are many effects resulting from pushing/not pushing the button, let's see what this says in relation to airplanes. The statement that Desmond failing to push the button once caused the crash of Oceanic 815 should mean then that once the button was being pushed again that there would be no more crashes, and this is when Desmond started to push again and then Locke. Further, what element of chance chose exactly the moment that 815 was in the circle of influence that Desmond would miss his duty that he fulfilled faithfully for a very long period of time. When the button pushing stopped, the whole thing blew up and there were never to be any buttons pushed again. If we follow the logic, this either disabled the plane crashing effect of the island or meant that every plane that passed within a certain circle of influence should crash. Why, then, is it only the plane that has the Losties on it coming back that is impacted? There should have either been no impact, or there should have been a veritable graveyard of airplanes. No, I think Daniel is wrong, and that the Losties, at least the six, have some kind of eternal purpose in the history of the island, and they were destined to crash there the first time, and to return the second. Daniel is wrong, and now he is dead.
#5 anonymousalso on 2009-04-30 22:37 (Reply)
Who is Penelope's mom? In the notes it says "Eloise and Charles grandson," but we don't know that it is Eloise's do we?
Also, what happend to "the war" that Widmore sd. was coming to John? And Maybe Faraday is wrong and Eloise did mean to send Jack there so he could stop the "accident" since she knew she was going to kill Daniel.
#5.1 Chris (Homepage) on 2009-05-01 13:14 (Reply)
err, another slip by yours truly. You're right, there's no evidence that Penny is Eloise's. But, Widmore was there, and he might have something up his sleeve....
#5.1.1 Rich on 2009-05-19 05:43 (Reply)
In a previous episode this season, Widmore was forced off the island because he had a child with someone off island with another woman that was not an Other. At the end of this episode, it was revealed that Widmore was Daniel's father. So that makes Penny and Dan half-siblings. In one of the last two episodes, it is revealed that Eloise is pregnant, presumably with Dan.
#6 Seana on 2009-05-01 13:02 (Reply)
Although 1977 is Daniel's "present", it doesn't negate the life experiences he had up to that point, including having grown up, gotten the grant, travelled to the island with Charlotte, etc, which is where he would have developed the fondness for her, which is why he tried to prevent her coming back to the island, because he knew she would die. His "present" just means that he's not jumping through time anymore, he (they) are stuck in 1977 unless they can do something to change it.
#6.1 Chris (Homepage) on 2009-05-01 13:12 (Reply)
...I was under the impression that this 'fondess' for Charlotte was something related to his having met her before. And when she told him of the 'strange little man' it was pretty clear that he knew it was him, even though he (in his present) hadn't been there yet.... Or am I getting confused about something (which is likely!)
#7 angela on 2009-05-01 14:52 (Reply)
Some of Daniel's last words to Eloise were-'you knew this was going to happen and you sent me back anyway'...by going back to the island, Daniel has set into motion the series of events that he wanted to change. Eloise and Widmore knew this would be the case-and they sent their son to his death.
#8 angela on 2009-05-02 16:57 (Reply)
I love the theory that Charlie Hume is actually Charlie Pace...Charles Hieronymus Pace-Hieronymus is an acronym for "Hume's Irony"...love it! Young Charlie Hume gets left by mum in the hospital waiting room with Widmore just outside the hospital-after his speech about 'sacrificing his relationship with his daughter'...not such a big stretch that he would grab the kid-and we know that he has the connections to get to the island-he could totally arrange to have the kid taken back in time AND he has enough money to orchestrate EXACTLY who, when, and where the kid is adopted. Why hide Charlie with regular working class people-who would ever think to look for the grandson of a magnate in 'Simon's Butcher Shop'-which is by the by the same name used for the butcher shop that stored Locke body. I love this theory and hope that it holds up! I like the family connection as well-Daniel Faraday was shown playing piano on the Variable...fans know how Charlie felt about the piano his mother gave him and how he also played.
Add Comment

Enclosing asterisks marks text as bold (*word*), underscore are made via _word_.
Standard emoticons like :-) and ;-) are converted to images.
E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for E-Mail notifications

To prevent automated Bots from commentspamming, please enter the string you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.
CAPTCHA

 
 
Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry

No Trackbacks
Bookmark and Share
AddThis Feed Button

Quicksearch


LOST Links

Previous Articles

LOST: Namaste
Thursday, March 19 2009
LOST: LaFleur
Thursday, March 5 2009
LOST: The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham
Thursday, February 26 2009
LOST: 316 [Spoiler filled analysis ahead!]
Thursday, February 19 2009
LOST: 316 [Recap, SPOILERS!]
Thursday, February 19 2009
LOST: This Place is Death [Analysis - SPOILERS!]
Thursday, February 12 2009
LOST: This Place is Death [Recap - SPOILERS!]
Thursday, February 12 2009
LOST: The Little Prince [SPOILERS!!]
Thursday, February 5 2009
LOST: Jughead [Analysis]
Thursday, January 29 2009
LOST: Jughead [Recap]
Thursday, January 29 2009

Tags

analysis answers ben cast characters charlie charlotte christian claire desmond dharma episodes faraday finale flashforwards hatch hurley hydra interviews jack jacob jin juliet kate locke michael oceanic six others questions recap reviews rumors sawyer sayid season four spoilers sun theories time travel widmore

Syndicate This Blog

  • XML RSS 2.0 feed
  • ATOM/XML ATOM 1.0 feed
  • XML RSS 2.0 Comments
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to Google
Television Blogs -  Blog Catalog Blog Directory
Blog Directory - Blogged

Categories

  • XML cast news (85)
  • XML characters (170)
  • XML episodes (179)
  • XML facts (37)
  • XML interviews (35)
  • XML opinions (93)
  • XML planetlost news (8)
  • XML reviews (65)
  • XML rumors (125)
  • XML show news (72)
  • XML theories (133)

All categories

Archives

  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • Recent...
  • Older...

M412 Network

War Movie Reviews
GBodyForum
THX-1138.ORG
3Cylinders.com
PlanetLOST is a MEDIA412 experiment. ©2006-2007 All Rights Reserved.
LOST and all trademarks, copyrights, etc. associated with it are the property of ABC Television Networks. PlanetLOST is not affiliated with or endorsed by ABC Television in any way.